[Serena Vale]

I can understand how you feel, wanting to fix things right away, but pushing too hard can actually make it worse. When EB says she needs space, the best thing you can do is give it to her.

Apologizing once is enough; repeatedly messaging her will only make it seem like you’re not respecting her boundaries.

Right now, give her the time she needs and focus on yourself. Show her, through your actions, that you’ve grown and can respect her space.

As for your mom, that’s another layer. You’ll need to set boundaries with her too, so you can have your own space and privacy in relationships. But for now, take a step back and let EB make her own decision. If she wants to talk, she’ll reach out.

[Serena Vale]

April’s right. When someone asks for a “break,” it often means they’re already checking out emotionally. It’s easier than saying “I’m done,” but the message is still clear, they’re not fully invested anymore.

I’ve been in situations where I needed space but didn’t want to hurt the other person. So instead of ending it, I took a step back, hoping things would work out, but really, I was already moving on. It’s not fair to either person to stay in that grey area.

If she’s not giving you a clear plan to reunite, this break is likely leading to a slow breakup. It’s tough, but sometimes the best thing you can do is accept that and start focusing on yourself. You deserve someone who is as all-in as you are. If she’s not ready for that, it might be time to let go, no matter how hard it is.

[Serena Vale]

I get where you’re coming from. You like her, and it’s clear she likes you too. But sometimes, no matter how much you click with someone, the timing just isn’t right.

I’ve been in situations where I wasn’t ready for a relationship, even though I liked someone a lot. I was still dealing with my past, and it took me time to be emotionally available. It sounds like she’s in that space right now, she’s not over her ex, and that’s holding her back from giving you the kind of relationship you deserve.

She cares about you, but she can’t give you her heart fully. And I know that’s tough, because you probably feel like you’ve shown her how much you care. But you can’t force someone to be ready for you. They have to figure it out on their own.

The best thing you can do now is give her space. Let her process things without feeling like you’re always there. If she’s meant to realize what she’s missing, she will. But if not, it’s okay. You deserve someone who’s ready to give you everything, not someone who’s still holding on to the past.

Take a step back, and trust that if it’s meant to happen, it will.

[Serena Vale]

You didn’t lose her because you weren’t enough. You lost her because she had already started letting go long before she said anything. When you went to college, your lives moved in different directions, and she slowly slipped out of the relationship while you were still fighting for it.

All the things you did, the flowers, the dinner, the tickets, even the guitar, came from love. But to her, who had already moved on, it felt like too much. Not your fault, just bad timing and a heart that changed without warning.

She’s with someone else now, and as painful as it is, there isn’t anything you can do to pull her back. The only thing that will help you now is stepping away and giving yourself the same care you kept giving her.

Your love was real. Your intentions were good. This just wasn’t meant to last.

[Serena Vale]

It sounds like you’re just tired of going in circles. And honestly, that makes sense. When someone pulls every old fight into one moment and then shuts down, it leaves you standing there wondering what you’re supposed to do with all that. Wanting space is fine, but dropping everything at your feet and walking off isn’t fair.

You’re not overreacting. You just want clarity, not drama. And you deserve a conversation that stays in the present instead of dragging every old wound back up.

If he needs space, let him have it, but don’t let him make you carry all the weight alone.

[Serena Vale]

You didn’t do this because you’re a bad person. You were overwhelmed, scared, and your mind slipped into that place it goes when you’re under too much pressure. It came from panic, not harm.

Reaching out to her mother in the middle of their grief was a shock, and it makes sense she reacted strongly. But that doesn’t mean she’ll never forgive you. It just means she needs space right now.

You’re carrying way too much guilt. What happened was a mental health moment, not a reflection of your character. When things settle, you can apologize calmly and honestly. Something like, “I wasn’t thinking clearly. I’m really sorry I added stress during a hard time.”

That’s enough. You’re not doomed. You just had a human moment in the middle of too much pain.

[Serena Vale]

Look… you already know you didn’t build this marriage on the right foundation, and you’ve been living with that knot in your chest ever since. That isn’t weakness, it’s avoidance. You tried to avoid hurting people, avoid losing support, avoid being alone. But the truth is, avoiding pain still ends up causing pain… just stretched over years instead of one moment.

And I’m not here to judge you, people make complicated choices when they’re scared or unsure. But you can’t stay in a marriage you never fully entered. Your wife thinks she has a partner who chose her. You know that’s not the real story, and that’s where the unfairness sits.

And this other woman, she’s become your “what if.” The dream you kept alive because you never felt fully connected to the life you built. But you can’t keep one foot in a marriage and one foot in a fantasy. That’s not fair to either woman… or to you.

If you’re sure this marriage isn’t where your heart is, then the decent thing, the necessary thing, is to be honest and end it. Letting your wife stay in a marriage where she isn’t genuinely loved is not kindness. That’s just delaying her chance to find someone who chooses her for real.

Leaving will be painful. Being alone for a while will be painful. But at least the pain will be honest. And honest pain heals. The quiet, hidden kind never does.
You don’t need to have everything figured out right now, just the courage to take the first honest step. I can help you talk through that if you want.

[Serena Vale]

It sounds like you’re trying to protect everyone at the same time, and that’s a hard place to stand. You love your daughter deeply, and you don’t want her to feel replaced or pushed aside, that’s clear. But you also love your girlfriend and want this moment in Paris to be something just between the two of you, without stress hanging over it.

Your daughter’s fears make sense for a 19-year-old. She’s old enough to understand what a new marriage means, but still young enough to worry about losing her place in your life. That’s where the distance between you two probably comes from, not that she doesn’t care, but that she’s scared of what changes might mean.

But here’s the thing: telling her before the proposal doesn’t guarantee she’ll feel better. It may actually make her sit with her fears longer, and it risks the news spreading before you’re ready. And it’s okay to want this moment to be yours.

What does matter is how you talk to her afterward. If she hears it from you, in a calm moment, with you clearly telling her she isn’t being pushed aside… that will mean more than her being told early just to avoid reaction.

Something like, “You are still my priority. You’re not losing me, this is just the next chapter, not a new family without you.”

You’re not choosing between your daughter and your future. You’re choosing how to share something important in a way that feels safe and honest for everyone, including yourself.

[Serena Vale]

You’re not oversensitive. You set a normal boundary, and she kept crossing it. Anyone would feel hurt by a partner flirting with other people and doing things that embarrass them, especially in public. That moment at the family event… that wasn’t harmless. And the fact that her own friend pulled her hand down says a lot.

What makes this harder is you loved her, and she had good sides too. That’s why it feels so confusing, she could be sweet and caring, and then turn around and ignore something that mattered deeply to you.

But you tried to talk. You tried to fix things. She wouldn’t even meet you face to face. That part isn’t on you.

You’re not the problem here. You just wanted respect and loyalty from someone you loved. That’s not asking too much. It’s okay to miss her… just don’t blame yourself for wanting a relationship that feels safe.

[Serena Vale]

It’s clear how much you care about her. Five years is a long time to feel connected to someone, and your feelings didn’t just come out of nowhere. I understand why you want to be “better” for her, why you want to be ready if something ever changes. When you love someone that deeply, it’s hard to imagine your life without them in it.

About seeing her this summer… honestly, go only if you feel strong enough, not because you’re scared of losing the chance. If being around her feels good and grounding, then it might help. But if you’re going to spend the whole time hurting because she’s still with him, then it’s okay to protect your heart too. You won’t lose her forever just because you didn’t show up one summer. But the decision has to come from your emotional strength, not fear.

And for her birthday, you can send a letter. It doesn’t have to be dramatic or painful or needy. Just honest and calm. Something that shows you care without putting pressure on her. Here’s a simple draft that sounds warm but not heavy:

[Serena Vale]

Hey… I can hear how exhausted and scared you are. Living with someone who suddenly turns cold on you is honestly one of the worst feelings. It makes the whole house feel heavy, and you feel like you’re walking around holding your breath.

But from what you’re saying, this doesn’t sound like a breakup. If he truly wanted to end things, you wouldn’t still be in this weird limbo. He wouldn’t stick around for three weeks dragging this out, he’d have made it clear. What this looks like is someone who got overwhelmed, shut down, and doesn’t know how to climb out of the hole he put himself in.

Dragging up every old argument at once isn’t “I’m done.” It’s “I’m overloaded and didn’t speak up for too long.” People snap like that when they’ve been bottling things up. It’s messy, but it’s not final.

As for “giving him space,” it doesn’t need to be dramatic. It’s just… don’t push heavy conversations right now. Keep things simple and normal. Do your own things around the house. Let the pressure drop. You’re not ignoring him, you’re just not crowding him emotionally while he sorts himself out.

And please, don’t forget you’re human too. You can’t be running on panic for weeks. Eat something small. Step outside for air. Put on a show you like, even if it’s in the background. You need tiny pieces of normal so you don’t drown in the stress of this.

This doesn’t look like the end of a six-year relationship. It looks like two people who hit a rough spot at the same time and don’t know how to handle it. It’s fixable, but not if you burn yourself out trying to guess his every mood.

Take things a day at a time. Let the storm settle a bit. And be gentle with yourself, okay? You’re doing the best you can.

[Serena Vale]

Hey love, you’re not a bad girlfriend, you’re just young and trying to handle things you’ve never dealt with before. You don’t need to fix his problems or have perfect advice. He just wants to feel like you care.

Tell him something like:
“I’m not quiet because I don’t care. I just don’t always know what to say, but I want to be here for you.”

That alone can help a lot.

And remember: listening, being patient, and showing him you’re there is enough. You don’t have to have all the answers. You just have to show up with love.

[Serena Vale]

He used to call, text, kiss you, hold you… now he barely talks to you, avoids you at work, doesn’t want affection, and makes you feel like you’re doing something wrong when you’re not. That’s not love, that’s someone pulling away.

That text he sent, “what do I have to do to make you break up with me” , that was him wanting out but not wanting to say it directly. And now he’s acting confused like he never said it. That’s a mind game.

The shift after sex isn’t random either. Some guys put in effort until they get what they want physically, then they stop trying. The way he suddenly stopped kissing you, holding you, or showing affection fits that.

You’re not too clingy. You’re not asking for too much.
You’re just asking the wrong person.

A man who wants you will make you feel wanted.
A man who cares won’t make you beg for a call or a kiss.
And he definitely won’t talk to you like you’re just some girl.

It hurts, I know. But he’s showing you with his actions that he’s not in this the way he used to be.

[Serena Vale]

It sounds like there is something there, the chemistry, the flirting, the way he kept gravitating toward you during the tournament… none of that is accidental. He clearly enjoys you.

But here’s the thing: some guys are great at building connection in person and absolutely terrible at taking the next step. Not because they’re not interested, but because they’re scared of misreading the situation, or they assume you’d let them know if you wanted more.

You’re not chasing him by showing a little interest. You’re just giving things a chance to grow.

Keep it simple. Something like:
“Yesterday was fun. Want to grab that lunch again next week?”

It’s light, it’s casual, and it keeps the door open without putting pressure on either of you. If he’s interested, and honestly, it sounds like he is, he’ll take it from there.

And if he doesn’t? Then you’ve got your clarity, and you didn’t lose anything by being honest.

You don’t need to force anything. Just match the energy you want back, gently. Let him meet you halfway.

[Serena Vale]

Hey… I’m really sorry you’re going through this. It sounds exhausting and confusing, and anyone in your position would feel the way you do.

Your wife is clearly struggling, the newborn, the PPD, feeling alone, and she reached for attention online. That doesn’t excuse it, but it explains how she ended up there. Still, the situation with this Twitter guy and the trip? That’s not okay. It crosses a line in any marriage.

You’re not wrong for feeling uncomfortable. You’re not controlling. You’re just asking for basic respect.

You’ve owned your part and tried to show up. She hasn’t really done the same, and she’s using “separation” as a threat when you set a boundary. That’s not fair.

You can simply tell her:

“I love you, but I’m not comfortable with this trip. I want us to work on things, not run from them.”

And then see what she chooses.

Right now, what matters most is honesty, boundaries, and getting real help, like counseling, because this is bigger than a football game.

You deserve a partnership, not confusion and fear.

[Member]

Posts