You’re in a tricky spot because the gift created an unintentional sense of obligation, but that doesn’t mean you owe him a romantic relationship. You’ve already been honest with him about not feeling the sparks and wanting to stay friends. so your boundaries are clear, even if the gift blurred them a bit.
Here’s the key: accepting a gift doesn’t mean you have to pursue romance, but continuing the friendship without setting boundaries can unintentionally send mixed signals. From April Masini’s advice, the healthiest approach is honesty and integrity. That means:
Acknowledge the gift: Let him know you appreciate it and his thoughtfulness. Reiterate your boundaries: Gently remind him you want to remain friends, but you don’t want to mislead him into thinking more is possible. Optional action with the gift: Some people return a gift if they feel it’s creating confusion, but it’s not strictly necessary if your message about friendship and boundaries is clear.
The goal is to protect both your friendship and his feelings without leading him on. Feeling guilty is natural, but guilt isn’t a reason to compromise your boundaries.