Your experience and your feelings are normal. And…. very few people end up marrying their first boyfriends or girlfriends. In other words, your first love is important, but it’s normal for it to not be your last love. That said, it’s very difficult to break up with someone you are not fighting with, or who hasn’t treated you badly. When there’s no drama to signal a problem, it’s very difficult to give up the good for what may be out there for you. Usually a fight or bad behavior is a flashing red light that it’s time to go. Your flashing light is yellow, and your interest in moving on has to do with your instinct that while you love your boyfriend — and probably always will — you’d like to experience more of life. He didn’t do anything wrong, but you’re you, and you have an idea of what you’d like for yourself and your life, and it’s different than what he wants for his life.