Your anxiety about his cheating on you is a guideline for you to use. Tune into it. Figure out what you feel and why you feel it. The problem here is that you’ve invested too much in only three months of dating this guy. The imbalance between too much investment and not enough knowledge about him creates your anxiety. Because you’re invested so quickly, you’ve got a lot to lose because you haven’t really gotten to know him well. Because you have a history of people cheating on you, you should wait to get to know a guy very, very well before getting too involved if only to protect yourself. 🙂 Having anxiety about a relationship is no fun!
So, use the first three months of dating someone to get to know them and decide if you want to continue dating each other. During this time you should assume he’s playing the field, and he should assume the same. If you do want to continue dating each other, use the second three months of dating to decide if you want to be monogamous. When you meet online, you can usually be assured that he’s dating other people for at least the first three months and possibly more — and that’s not wrong. In fact, it’s prudent! Dating is competitive and especially if you’re both divorced, you may both want to try and get it right this time around, and learn from what hasn’t worked in the past.
Since you’ve seen that his online dating profile is still up, be smart. He’s playing the field — even if he says he loves you. It’s only been three months. it’s too soon for a commitment, so drop the online dating profile issue. He’s dating. Or simply looking — with the intent to date. It’s not the end of the world. It just means you have competition. Don’t call him on this. Instead, watch and learn. 😉 He’ll take it down when he’s ready, and that’s how you’ll know he’s into you.
Lastly, slow down and back off the living half time with him and involving your kids in his life until you’re more secure that this is going to go the distance. When you have less riding on the success of a new relationship, you’ll feel less anxious about making sure it works, and you’ll be able to focus your energy on figuring out if you’re compatible.
Hope that helps!