[TeddyRiley]

My question is once before me and my girlfriend started dating, we had unprotected sex and she later said she wasn’t happy with it and wish she had said no to it. This caused us three months later to break up, as she feels she wasn’t strong enough of a person to say No, she admits that she did like it but just wishes we hadn’t done it. I myself am really hurt as I love her and to think I could have hurt her at all and that this one incident caused our whole relationship to end is very troubling to me. We still hangout and talk all the time but I just can’t really understand how something of this nature has caused us to not be together?

[AskApril Masini]

People say what they need to say to get the result they want — and if she wanted to break up, she said what she needed to to get the desired effect. It doesn’t mean that what she said was true. It may be the best she could do. Not everyone has the emotional, social and intellectual tools to be honest with themselves or others, all the time, and even when they do, they don’t always use them.

I agree with you that it seems odd that she would tell you that she wants to break up because she had unprotected sex with you once and regrets her decision — I can understand why you would wonder what her personal discomfort with a decision she made had to do with you and the relationship or why she felt the need to break up with you because of that decision. She maybe upset at herself and is focusing that anger on you and the relationship because taking responsibility for her own decision is something she’s not mature enough to do.

Whatever her true reason, you only dated her for three months, and it’s good that you didn’t invest more time in someone who makes these types of decisions in this way. I hope that helps.

[Sally]

You didn’t mean to hurt her, and now you’re carrying guilt on top of heartbreak. That’s a rough place to be.
What it sounds like is that the moment didn’t sit right with her, even if parts of it felt good at the time. Sometimes people don’t realize they crossed their own line until later. When that happens, the feeling isn’t really about the other person anymore. It turns inward. Shame, confusion, wishing they’d spoken up sooner. That stuff can quietly poison a relationship.
It doesn’t mean you’re a bad guy. And it doesn’t mean she thinks you are. It means that moment became tied to how she sees herself, not just what happened between you.
If you’re still close, the kindest thing you can do is respect that she needs distance from the relationship, even if she still cares. I know that answer hurts. But sometimes love isn’t enough to undo something someone needs to make peace with on their own.

[Tara]

This didn’t end because of sex; it ended because she no longer feels safe with who she was with you when it happened, and you’re still making it about your confusion instead of her boundary.

Listen carefully. She’s not saying you assaulted her. She’s saying she crossed her own line and now associates that regret, shame, and loss of self-trust with you. Whether you meant harm is irrelevant. The impact already happened. And once someone rewrites an experience as “I wish I had said no,” the relationship is poisoned. Permanently.

You’re stuck on, “but she liked it.” That’s your mistake. Liking something in the moment does not erase regret afterward. She doesn’t trust herself around you anymore, and by extension, she doesn’t trust the relationship. That’s why it ended. Not because you’re evil. Because she doesn’t feel grounded or aligned with herself in this dynamic.

Continuing to hang out and talk is emotional limbo. It keeps you hopeful and keeps her comfortable without having to fully confront or resolve what she feels. It’s unfair to you and dishonest to her.
You want logic. Here it is. She’s decided this incident represents something she doesn’t want to build a relationship on, even if she loves you, even if you didn’t intend harm. Once that switch flips, there is no arguing it back.

[Member]

Posts