[Sally]

I get why that one line threw you off. When someone says they want you to themselves and then adds a little escape hatch, it messes with your sense of safety. It makes you wonder if you imagined the closeness.

Here’s how it sounds to me. He likes you. He enjoys being with you. But he’s not fully ready to lock the door yet, even if part of him wants to. Some people move forward while still keeping a mental backup plan, not because they’re looking elsewhere, but because commitment scares them.

What matters is how this makes you feel. If that comment planted doubt, pay attention to that. You don’t need to panic or push. Just keep watching his actions. Clarity usually shows up there before it ever does in words.

[Sally]

When someone comes back after years, it stirs up curiosity and what-ifs, especially when you’ve never really been in a relationship before. Missing the talking doesn’t automatically mean you miss him. Sometimes it just means he filled a quiet space in your day.

What matters is his behavior. Cancelling twice at the last minute, pulling back, and keeping things mostly online isn’t someone moving forward. It’s someone who likes the attention but not the follow-through. That’s confusing on purpose or by habit, but either way it leaves you hanging.

If you keep talking to him, expect more of the same. If that already hurts, it’s okay to step back. You don’t owe anyone access just because they once showed interest. Trust how uneven this already feels.

[Sally]

Her behavior is all over the place, and that kind of push-pull can mess with your head fast.
It does sound like she likes the attention and the flirting. The cookies, the heart, the I love you stuff… that’s not nothing. But liking attention isn’t the same as being ready for something real. Ignoring you after getting close usually means she’s unsure, scared, or just not ready to follow through.

Try not to chase the highs and lows. If she really wanted to hang out, you wouldn’t be left guessing this much. I’d slow it down. Be friendly, but stop reading into mixed signals. If she wants more, she’ll make it clear. And if she doesn’t, you deserve someone who doesn’t keep you hanging like this.

[Sally]

I know how badly you want to believe she still loves you. I really do. But reading this, it sounds like she already said goodbye in every way she knew how.
She didn’t leave because she stopped caring overnight. She left because the relationship stopped feeling safe and light for her. The jealousy, the control, the pressure that stuff wears someone down, even when there’s love underneath it.

The back-and-forth after the breakup wasn’t hope. It was her trying to ease out without hurting you more, and you kept reaching because you weren’t ready to let go. That doesn’t make you weak. It makes you human. But it did push her further away.

Right now, the only chance of anything changing is stopping completely. No messages. No convincing. No proving. Not to get her back but to get yourself steady again.
Love can exist and still be over. And I know that hurts like hell.

[Sally]

The problem isn’t just his ex. It’s that he keeps choosing her comfort over your peace, over and over. Being friends for decades doesn’t excuse hiding you, sharing private things about you, or letting her stir up drama that hurts you.

What really stands out is that you’re never allowed in the same space as her, yet she’s allowed way too much space in your relationship. That’s not balance. And when you’re upset, instead of listening, he gets mad or spiritual about forgiveness. That leaves you alone with your feelings.

Love should feel safe. Right now you’re constantly second-guessing and checking phones because you don’t feel backed up. That’s exhausting. If he can’t clearly choose you and protect the relationship, this will keep eating at you. You’re not wrong for feeling this way.

[Sally]

This isn’t really about one night or one back rub. It’s about control and fear. You didn’t harm him. You didn’t disrespect his health. You tried to connect with the man you love and stopped when you felt it wasn’t mutual. That matters.

Apologizing over and over won’t fix this because he’s not asking for an apology. He’s asking for reassurance that things will always be on his terms. And that’s a heavy place to live in.

You can tell him you understand his boundaries and that you’ll respect them. But you’re also allowed to say you don’t want to feel like your touch is a problem. If he won’t talk, that silence is saying something too.
Love shouldn’t feel this fragile.

[Sally]

When you’re attracted to someone, especially someone confident and kind, your brain starts connecting dots fast. And professors can feel extra intense because they’re focused, attentive, and in a position of authority.

Most of what you described also fits someone who’s just friendly, engaged, and good at their job. Remembering details, joking, helping out, being relaxed with you in class that’s not rare for professors who actually like teaching and connecting with students.

The touching and teasing is the only part that blurs things a little, but even that can still sit in harmless territory. If he truly crossed a line, you’d feel it more clearly, not just wonder.
Right now, it sounds like a crush mixed with proximity and attention. Try to keep your feet on the ground. Let it stay where it belongs in your head and protect yourself.

[Sally]

Losing a crush is one thing. Losing the feeling of belonging in a little trio like that is another kind of pain. It makes you question yourself, even though you didn’t do anything wrong.

From where I’m sitting, it sounds like he pulled back because he didn’t know how to handle your feelings, and instead of dealing with it directly, he shifted closer to her. And your girl friend brushing it off? That stings, especially since she knew your heart was involved.

I don’t think you need to dramatically cut them off, but I do think you need some space. Being around people who make you feel like an extra will just keep reopening the wound. Step back, focus on other friends, and let the intensity cool. If they really care, they’ll notice your absence. And if they don’t, that tells you something too.

[Sally]

You waited years to finally be with him, and now it feels like you’re dating his parents’ schedule instead of him.
The hard part is this isn’t really about them. It’s about him not setting limits. Adults with overbearing parents usually don’t mean to hurt anyone, but the result is still the same: you keep getting pushed aside. And that wears on you fast.

You’re allowed to say how this affects you without attacking his family. Keep it simple. Tell him you like him, but the constant canceling makes you feel like an afterthought. See how he responds. Not what he promises, but what actually changes.
If nothing changes, this is likely what the relationship will always feel like. And it’s okay to admit that’s not enough for you.

[Sally]

Things really can shift that fast, especially early on, and I know how confusing that feels when everything seemed warm just days ago.
From the outside, it sounds like she enjoyed your time together, but something about the last few messages may have felt like too much, too soon for her. Not wrong. Not creepy. Just more intensity than she was ready to hold. When some people feel overwhelmed, they don’t explain. They go quiet.

Right now, the best thing you can do is stop reaching out. You’ve said enough. More messages won’t bring clarity, they’ll only add pressure. If she wants to continue, she knows how to find you.
You didn’t imagine the connection. But early sparks don’t always turn into flames. Sometimes they just fade. And that hurts, even at 65.

[Sally]

You didn’t miss your chance because you’re careless or cruel. You missed it because you were scared and trying to protect yourself. That happens more than people admit.
The hard truth is this: you taught her not to choose you. You told her over and over not to get attached, so when she finally did feel something with someone else, she believed you meant it. That doesn’t make you a bad guy. It just means timing mattered, and it went the wrong way.

Right now, waiting around would only keep you stuck. That wouldn’t be romantic, it would be painful. Blocking each other was probably the kindest thing, even though it feels awful.
Take this as a lesson, not a life sentence. Next time, say it sooner. You’re not too late for love. Just this version of it.

[Sally]

From the outside, it sounds like she still cares about you, but not enough to actually move toward you. Asking who you’re with, checking if you’re solo, bringing up Valentine’s that’s curiosity and attachment. It’s not the same as wanting to rebuild something. People can miss you and still not want the relationship back.

The disappearing act after those moments is the key part. If she wanted more, she’d lean in, not fade out. The playful response when you said you missed her shows she liked hearing it, but she didn’t meet you there.

Right now, you’re doing more emotional reaching than she is. That’s your answer. Mixed signals usually mean mixed intentions. And that’s a tough place to stay too long.

[Sally]

This is one of those situations where everything blows up at once and you’re left standing there without any control. Anyone would be heartbroken.
Here’s the hard part, said gently. If his parents can block you completely and move another woman in, it means he’s letting them run his life right now. And if there really is a pregnancy, things just got way bigger than feelings alone.

Trying to force contact will likely make it worse and put you in a position where you look like the problem, even though you’re not. If he wants to reach you, he knows exactly how. Right now, he’s choosing not to, or he’s unable to.

I know that hurts more than anything. But chasing someone who isn’t choosing you will only break you down. Protect your heart first. Even love has limits.

[Sally]

From Jim’s side, it probably felt like loyalty got crossed, even if your heart was in the right place. When friends, secrets, and couples get tangled up, people don’t react logically. They react emotionally. He likely feels embarrassed, guilty, and protective of his friendship, and instead of sorting that out, he’s sitting in it. That’s why he seems sad and distant.

I don’t think Cara was trying to sabotage you. I think she was hurting and grabbing for clarity wherever she could. That doesn’t make her evil, just human.
Your relationship can be saved, but only if Jim actually talks about why this hit him so hard instead of shutting down. You can’t fix something you’re not allowed to understand. Give it a little space, but don’t ignore the quiet tension. It matters.

[Sally]

Sexting feels light until it doesn’t, and then suddenly you’re attached without meaning to be. That shift you’re feeling is normal. You got comfortable, you let your guard down, and now there’s something at stake.

From what you’re describing, it sounds like he likes the attention and the connection, but he’s keeping one foot out. The comments about other girls feel intentional, even if he’d never admit it. That’s usually someone trying to stay in control of the vibe, reminding you not to expect too much.

The hard part is this: if he wanted more, you’d feel less confused. Mixed signals are still a signal. You don’t have to cut him off, but you might want to notice how this is making you feel. Fun shouldn’t leave you second-guessing yourself this much.

[Member]

Posts